Lou Stagner's Newsletter #129

One Reason You Choke Under Pressure (And How to Stop)

Weekly Quiz!

To see correct answer, click “CONTINUE” button at the bottom of the next page.

Good luck! 😀 

Scratch players from 200 yards in the fairway: What percent of their shots finish more than 20 yards short of the hole?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

Why You Choke Under Pressure (And How to Stop)

You've practiced this putt a thousand times. But now there's something riding on it, and suddenly your hands feel foreign and the putter feels like it weighs 10 pounds. You jab at it. You miss.

That's choking. And a study by Sian Beilock and Thomas Carr at Michigan State University figured an interesting way to train yourself so you reduce the chances of “choking”.

The Study

Beilock and Carr ran four experiments. The two I want to focus on involved training golfers in the lab and then testing them under pressure.

In their “Experiment 3”, 108 participants were split into three groups. All practiced the same putting the same way, hit putts to a target from various distances on an indoor green. The difference was the training environment.

Group 1 (Single-Task): Normal practice. Just putt.

Group 2 (Distraction): Putted while listening to a recording of words and pressing a foot pedal every time they heard a target word. Their attention was split.

Group 3 (Self-Consciousness): Putted while being filmed by a video camera. They were told coaches at the university would review the footage.

All three groups improved at similar rates during training. Then came the pressure test. Participants were told they could earn money, but only if both they AND a partner improved by 20%. If either fell short, neither got paid.

The Results

Under pressure, the single-task group choked. Their putting accuracy declined significantly (p < .04).

The distraction group choked too. Even worse, actually (p < .005).

The self-consciousness group? They got BETTER under pressure.

“Experiment 4” confirmed this with 32 more participants trained over a longer period. Early in learning, everyone improved under pressure. But later, after the skill had become more automatic, only the self-consciousness group continued to improve. The distraction group fell apart.

Why This Happens

Here's the mechanism. With practice, your putting stroke becomes procedural. It runs on autopilot. You don't think about each step, you just do it. That's a good thing... until pressure hits.

Pressure raises self-consciousness. It makes you want to monitor and control each part of your stroke. That monitoring disrupts the automatic process. The result? You're essentially putting like a beginner again.

The golfers who trained while being filmed had already adapted to performing under self-aware conditions. Pressure didn't introduce anything new for them. They'd been practicing with that feeling the entire time.

My Thoughts

This study is interesting.

Most of us practice in a bubble. No pressure, no consequences, no one watching. That feels comfortable, but it doesn't prepare you for the moments that matter.

The takeaway is practical. Film yourself practicing. Putt with a friend watching. Create consequences. Make small wagers. Put yourself in situations where you feel that self-conscious pressure DURING practice, so it doesn't ambush you on the course.

You can't eliminate pressure. But you can make it familiar.

See you next week!

 Finally...

  • Advertise your business to 38,000+ readers of this newsletter.

  • Shop Arccos Golf here. (Use code DATALOU15 to save 15%)

  • Join Team Titleist here.

  • Shop StrackaLine Green Books here. (Use code DATALOU15 to save 15%)

  • Listen to the “Hack it Out Golf” podcast on Apple or Spotify.

  • Submit ideas or feedback here.

    Have a great week!

Lou Stagner